Social media offers everyone the same basic promise: post something about yourself and get responses from other people. Whether it’s a holiday, a promotion or just a midweek meal, these days many people’s lives are shared online.
But could it be that what users feel they get back from the exchange depends on their personality? Our research has found that people who are higher in a trait called “narcissistic admiration” tend to be more positive about their online interactions. Narcissistic admiration is when someone goes out of their way to attract attention and validation as a way of boosting their self-esteem.
At the same time, those higher in narcissistic rivalry (positioning themselves as superior to others) and narcissistic vulnerability (those struggling with insecurity) reported fewer favourable social outcomes.
We initially thought differences in how they presented themselves online might help to explain these differences. But when we followed people’s actual social media posts over three weeks, we found that wasn’t the case. Instead, our findings pointed towards another possibility. What people expect from social media, and whether they feel they get it, may be an important part of the story.
We often use the term “narcissistic” to describe someone who loves attention. But narcissistic traits exist on a continuum – we all have them to some degree. Psychologists also distinguish between narcissistic traits.
Narcissistic admiration involves wanting to stand out, impress others and gain admiration and status. Narcissistic rivalry is more antagonistic and involves maintaining superiority, partly by devaluing others.
Vulnerable narcissism looks different. People higher in this trait tend to have a more fragile sense of self and greater sensitivity to rejection and how they feel they are being judged by their peers.
What people really think of us
Social media is an interesting environment in which to study these traits. It offers opportunities to attract attention and admiration, but also frequent feedback about whether other people have responded as we hoped.
In our research, we examined more than 1,000 social media users across Brazil, Indonesia and the UK. Participants completed questionnaires measuring their levels of narcissistic admiration, rivalry and vulnerability, alongside questions about what they felt they gained from their social media interactions.
People higher in narcissistic admiration tended to feel they gained more from their social media interactions. This included factors such as greater levels of attention and validation, and more opportunities to initiate relationships.
Those higher in narcissistic rivalry and vulnerability reported less favourable experiences. They felt less close to others and that they received less attention. This raised an obvious question: why?
One possibility was that people with different narcissistic traits were simply presenting themselves differently online. So, in another paper we looked much more closely at what happened in people’s everyday social media lives.
We followed 154 adults over 21 days, repeatedly asking them about posts they had made. Participants told us what they expected to get from their posts and, later, what they felt they had received. We also asked about their wellbeing.
Some of the patterns we’d found previously appeared again. People higher in narcissistic admiration reported more favourable daily interpersonal outcomes. Those higher in rivalry reported poorer outcomes when it came to relationships – that is, initiating them, maintaining them and staying close to people. Vulnerable narcissism was associated with lower levels of closeness and less ability to maintain relationships.
But differences in how people presented themselves online didn’t explain this variation in perceived social outcomes. Instead, people’s expectations provided an intriguing clue.

People higher in vulnerable narcissism expected to be more popular and get more attention and validation from their social media posts than they subsequently felt they received.
Vulnerable narcissism was also consistently associated with lower wellbeing in this study. And when people expected a post to help manage their relationships but then felt that it hadn’t, this mismatch was more keenly felt among those with higher levels of vulnerable narcissism.
This doesn’t mean that unmet expectations caused poorer wellbeing. Nor did we objectively count every like, comment or message that our participants received. Our findings concern people’s perceptions of what they got back.
But it suggests that understanding people’s experiences of social media may require looking beyond what they post. Who we are and what we expect from other people may matter too.
So what can we do with this? Our findings don’t suggest that people should simply expect less from social media. Wanting connection, attention or reassurance from other people is a normal part of life.
But they do suggest that it may be useful to think about what we are expecting a post to achieve. Are we sharing something because we want to connect with others? Are we looking for reassurance or validation? Are we hoping that one particular person will respond?
If the response feels disappointing, it may be worth considering not only what came back, but also what we had hoped would happen. Becoming more aware of those expectations may help us to understand our own reactions to social media. Otherwise, we could assume that how we feel is simply a consequence of the response itself.
There is a broader lesson here too. Discussions about whether social media is “good” or “bad” for our wellbeing often focus on platforms, screen time or what people post. Our findings add another layer: the same online environment may be experienced very differently depending on the person using it and what they hope to get from it.