Housing in the UK has become markedly less affordable over the last 25 years. Between 2000 and 2025, English house prices rose by about 250% in cash terms (roughly 85% in real terms), while median earnings only doubled in cash terms, and rose by around 10% in real terms.
The median English house price is now over seven times median full-time earnings, up from around four in 2000. The increasing disconnect between house prices and wage growth is hitting first-time buyers particularly hard.
Mortgage deposits present the biggest hurdle to getting on the property ladder. While deposits varied until the 2008 financial crisis, 20% deposits have been the norm since 2009 – now an insurmountable barrier for most first-time buyers.
To address this problem, the UK government keeps reaching for the same fix: equity loan schemes for first-time buyers. The first of these was the 2013-2023 Help to Buy scheme in England. The UK government announced its successor, Your First Home, in September 2026. It will be available from February 2027.
The goal of these schemes is noble, but supporting market entry in this way could potentially pour fuel onto an already overheating market. This was exactly what happened with Help to Buy, which offered first-time buyers a government loan of up to 20% of a new-build property’s price (40% in London from 2016). Buyers had to provide a 5% deposit.
The government’s evaluation report showed that the scheme supported over 387,000 purchases. It also stimulated housebuilding – around 15% of all new dwellings built in England from 2013 to 2023 are attributable to the scheme.
However, the report also finds that it contributed to higher house prices, as it raised the purchasing power of house buyers without substantially increasing the number of homes. Comparing prices in the Wales/England border region, prices were around 2% higher on the English side, where Help to Buy was introduced one year ahead of Wales.

Labour’s new Your First Home scheme was announced in September and ratified in the October budget, amid accusations that it will have the same effect. Ministers claim that Your First Home will avoid the pitfalls of its predecessor through income caps, targeting the scheme at those that cannot get some or all of the deposit from their parents (the “bank of mum and dad”).
Your First Home gives first-time buyers of new builds a 20% equity loan (40% in London), interest-free for the first five years, with regional price caps. Buyers only need a minimum deposit of 2.5%, cannot provide more than a 15% deposit, and there is a household income cap of £110,000 (or £140,000 in London).
Help to Buy included no income caps, and buyers needed a 5% deposit (with no upper cap). Despite these changes, Your First Home will likely have the same impact.
Read more: The real reason abolishing stamp duty won’t help first-time buyers
No meaningful difference
Our research has tested the effect of these changes to equity loans in a computational model of the English housing market. We found that there is no material difference in market effects between the two schemes: both lead to the same kinds of price increases for owner-occupier homes.
We tested some hypotheses in model experiments. We looked at whether house price inflation could be curbed through better targeting – either through the lower deposit requirement or different salary caps. We also tested the effects of restricting eligibility to new homes only.
We found that reducing the buyer deposit from 5% to 2.5% made no significant difference in house price outcomes: both stimulated the market equally. However, salary caps had the potential to curb house price inflation, but they had to be relatively low.
A salary cap of £50,000 (coupled with a house price cap at £300,000) had almost no inflationary effect, and each £10,000 increase lead to proportionate price rises. It made little difference to house price inflation whether access was restricted to new homes or any homes on the open market.
Interestingly, in our model, the new scheme did lead to lower local rents. With more renters able to access the mortgage market – a likely effect of the low 2.5% deposit requirement – demand for rental housing would decrease. In turn, landlords would lower rents or put homes up for sale, thus increasing the supply in the owner-occupier market.
Read more: Buying your first home? Here’s how to increase your chances of getting a mortgage
An incomplete solution
The conclusion from our analysis is that there is no silver bullet for making housing more affordable, other than the long-term solution of building more homes to consistently increase supply.
If the government genuinely wants to increase access to housing without further pricing people out of the market, income caps have to be considered carefully.
Although Your First Home has an income cap, it is too high. It currently equates to the combined salaries of two people both earning near the top 10% of earners, and will not restrict access in any meaningful way.
Short-term fixes, involving either subsidies for some sectors or increased taxes (for example on expensive housing), are extremely difficult to design without also causing unintended effects – not just for those buying and selling houses, but also for those who rent, since the rental and the purchase markets are so closely intertwined.
The new scheme will undoubtedly allow some people to fulfil their dream of home ownership. But for many, it could exacerbate the housing crisis even further.